Search This Blog

Wednesday, June 1, 2011

Google's+Matt+Cutts+Debunk+Flowchart+By+Danny+Sullivan

Google's+Matt+Cutts+Debunk+Flowchart+By+Danny+Sullivan

How Google Decides When To Debunk SEO Nonsense

Jun 1, 2011 • 8:37 am | comments (2)by Barry Schwartz twitter | Filed Under Other Google Topics


As you can imagine, Google spends too much time debunking false and misunderstood information on how Google works. We covered one this morning on email marketing's effect on rankings. To be honest, we have posted some things in the seven plus years on writing on search that Google was upset with. It happens, Google has a PR team to deal with it and Matt Cutts, amongst other Google engineers, are frequently debunking false information.

Danny Sullivan put together an outstanding chart named The Matt Cutts Debunking Flowchart. It is a somewhat humorous but sometimes true flowchart of how Matt and his team decide when to debunk this information. From conspiracy theories to just wrong information, to making Google look better when they really are somewhat wrong. The large flowchart is at Search Engine Land, but here is a smaller sized version.

Google's Matt Cutts Debunk Flowchart By Danny Sullivan

So what were some of the recent debunking Google has done? Matt Cutts posted them atHackerNews:

  • Claiming that your email newsletter's Gmail reputation affects your ranking: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2600933 I did a full debunk here: http://goo.gl/6A8f9
  • Claiming that Hacker News was penalized by Panda: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2595704 I did a full debunk here: http://goo.gl/7Tw9o
  • There was an SEO blog that had a headline "Google Copying Bing's Image Results? Google Cheating Bing?" at http://www.seroundtable.com/google-indexing-bing-13477.html when in fact it was just images on bing.net and Bing neglected to have a robots.txt file. We have a policy against search results in search results, so we were happy to remove the images in less than a day. The SEO blogger changed the headline to be less sensational.
  • Oh, one more debunk: http://allthingsd.com/20110527/google-no-government-investig... The webspam team continues to take manual action to remove spam in the same way that we have for the last decade.
  • Those are the four debunks that come to mind from the last week or so. Sigh.

Of course I take a little issue with my story but I won't argue here.

The chart is fun and I can totally relate to this on a much smaller scale
.

4 comments:

  1. It is very awesome published. Love to read it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Google Enabling some data authentication processes due to this debunk may occur.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like it so much. It was nutrients and wish you can provide us some more guidelines. Everybody knows that dofollow is very awesome for any website. Do adhere to weblog performs a primary part for the improve a website pr in the seo work. Thanks for it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Amazing guidelines for a beginner like me. I organized to begin with more but i can't take over with it. But as you said, it’s better to begin more slowly, i.e. 3 content weekly and improve it progressively with time. I will search for this. Thanks for indicating useful tip to be effective blog writer.:)

    ReplyDelete

Add your valuable comments